Thanksgiving at a family table in Hamilton, Alabama, is not a quiet meal. It’s a crowd, a blessing, and a table that runs out of room before it runs out of food. The cooking that raised this site came off farms in that part of Alabama — corn and soybean fields, big gardens, and foodways that still show up in what we cook: pink-eye peas instead of black-eyed, mustard greens cooked down the way they ought to be.
So when Thanksgiving comes around at Joy of Grilling, the oven can take the day off. The grill and the smoker can carry the whole meal — the bird, the sides, the pie — and give you back the one thing an oven never does: a reason for everybody to gather outside around the fire while dinner comes together.
Our Thanksgivings in Hamilton, Alabama, always ran ten to twenty people — aunts, great-grandmothers and grandmothers, uncles, cousins, everyone together. We put all our cooking experience to work, and everyone helped each other. It was just a big synergy, really, of Southern love.
And at our table, the greens and the peas weren’t bought — they were grown. We had a large field of mustard greens, and pink-eye peas alongside them. Most people think of black-eyed peas, and we love those too — but in Hamilton, the pink-eye is king of the pea: a little sweeter, with a taste all its own. Both of them were on our Thanksgiving table.
The Menu
Something to graze on first. Start folks with a bowl of Smoky Pink-Eyed Pea Dip with Charred Scallions — pink-eye peas are Hamilton family food, and a smoky dip buys you peace while the turkey finishes. A platter of Turkey Meatballs with Cranberry Glaze gives early arrivals a first taste of the day.
The bird. The centerpiece is the Classic Dry-Brined Smoked Turkey — dry-brined ahead, smoked low and slow, carved juicy. Whichever bird you choose, it starts with The Classic Turkey Brine and ends with Grill-Roasted Turkey Gravy from Drippings, because Thanksgiving without gravy is just a meeting.
Running short on time? A Spatchcocked Grilled Turkey with Herb Butter lies flat and cooks in a fraction of the time, with crisp skin all over. Feeding a smaller table? The Grilled Turkey Breast with Maple-Bourbon Glaze is sweet, smoky, and sized right — and the Grilled Turkey Breast Roulade with Cornbread Dressing rolls the dressing right inside, which solves two dishes at once.
The sides. This is where a Southern table shows off:
- Coal-Roasted Sweet Potatoes with Sorghum Pecan Butter — cooked in the coals themselves, split open, and finished with sorghum pecan butter. About as Alabama as it gets.
- Cast-Iron Smoked Mac and Cheese — baked in cast iron until it picks up real smoke. Make plenty; there is never plenty.
- Grilled Green Beans with Toasted Almonds — bright, simple, and exactly the relief a rich plate needs.
- Grilled Brussels Sprouts with Bacon — charred edges and bacon. Enough said.
- Creamed Pearl Onions — the holiday-table classic, baked golden under melted cheese. The first credited member of Sides That Steal the Show, from Corre Larkin — the side dish that steals the show is exactly what a Thanksgiving table needs.
- Maple-Glazed Bacon-Wrapped Carrots — alongside the creamed onions, set out the bacon-wrapped carrots: they come from Jeff & Lauren’s holiday table by way of ours, and they disappear at a speed that has nothing to do with how many you made.
- Hasselback Potatoes on the Grill — fanned thin so the edges crisp; they look like company cooking because they are.
- Honey-Glazed Grilled Carrots — a little sweetness and color where the table needs it.
The bread. Cast-Iron Skillet Cornbread on the Grill — buttermilk cornbread baked in a screaming-hot skillet right on the grate, sliced into wedges and served from the pan.
Save room. Dessert is Smoked Pecan Pie in a Cast-Iron Skillet — the Southern Thanksgiving pie, with a whisper of smoke in it — and for anyone who swears they’re too full, Grilled Pound Cake with Macerated Berries, toasted on the still-warm grill.
The Game Plan (working backward from the table)
Pick your serving time and walk it backward. Say dinner is at 4:00 — here’s the shape of the day. Adjust the hours to the bird you chose; the order matters more than the clock.
- Two to three days out: The turkey goes into its brine or dry brine (The Classic Turkey Brine). Make your shopping run. Breathe.
- The day before: Assemble what holds well — the mac and cheese can be built and refrigerated, beans trimmed, sprouts halved, carrots peeled. The pecan pie can be smoked a day ahead and nobody will ever know. Set the table tonight; tomorrow-you says thanks.
- Morning of: Bird out of the brine, dried, seasoned. Fire lit early. The turkey is the long pole in this tent — a whole smoked bird is a half-day project, so it goes on first, in the morning, and everything else schedules around it. (A spatchcocked bird shortens the whole day considerably.)
- While the turkey cooks: Steady, low work. The sweet potatoes can go into the coals to roast on their own schedule. Keep the coffee coming and leave the lid closed.
- When the turkey comes off: It rests, tented, a good long while — and that rest is your sides window. Grill space is free now: mac and cheese goes on to smoke and bake, then the fast sides in waves — Brussels sprouts, green beans, carrots, hasselback potatoes — each one quick over real heat.
- Last 30 minutes: Gravy from the drippings (Grill-Roasted Turkey Gravy from Drippings) — it has to be last, because it needs what the bird gave up. Dip goes out for the grazers. Carve the turkey.
- 4:00: Everything lands hot, nobody ran an oven marathon, and the cook actually got to be outside with everybody else. That’s the whole point.
The Day After Is Its Own Holiday
Leftover turkey is not a problem; it’s a second menu. Turn it into Turkey Soup with Grilled Vegetables, crisp it up in a Day-After Turkey Hash on the Griddle, tuck it under a crust in a Cast-Iron Turkey Pot Pie on the Grill, or let it ride in a Smoked Turkey and Sausage Gumbo. And the sandwich — there’s always the sandwich: Thanksgiving Leftover Turkey Sandwich with Cranberry Mayo.
More for the Holiday Table
- Cranberry Barbecue Sauce — for the relative who puts barbecue sauce on everything. Every family has one; feed him well.
- Apple Cider–Brined Grilled Turkey and Cajun-Injected Grilled Turkey — two more whole-bird routes, one sweet, one with some fire in it.
- Grilled Turkey Wings with Alabama White Sauce — for a smaller gathering or a second-meat option with Alabama in its name.
- Grilled Maple and Pecan Topped Butternut Squash — if your table wants one more vegetable with fall written all over it.
From our family table to yours — Happy Thanksgiving.
— Founder, Joy of Grilling

