Pork , brown sugar , mustard
Best for: Learning low-and-slow the honest way — one butt, one rub, no wrap, no shortcuts.
This is the master method every other pulled pork recipe builds on: a bone-in Boston butt, a balanced rub, and steady 250°F smoke from start to finish, unwrapped the whole way. No foil, no injection, no spritz schedule to memorize. The butt cooks until the fat has rendered, the bark has set deep and dark, and the meat gives up and pulls apart at the touch of a fork — usually somewhere between 195°F and 205°F, when a probe slides in like the meat is butter. Master this one and you own the foundation of American barbecue.
Grill: Indirect, low heat (250°F), unwrapped the whole cook. Equipment: Smoker or kettle grill set up for indirect cooking, instant-read thermometer, heatproof gloves. Course: Main dish.
Ingredients
Rest: 1 hour. Total: 11 hours 20 minutes.
Not sure when it’s done? Check the grilling temperatures & doneness chart.
The butt
- 1 bone-in Boston butt (about 8 pounds)
- 2 tablespoons yellow mustard, as a binder
The rub
- 1/4 cup packed brown sugar
- 1/4 cup paprika
- 2 tablespoons kosher salt
- 1 tablespoon black pepper
- 1 tablespoon garlic powder
- 1 tablespoon onion powder
- 2 teaspoons dry mustard
- 1 teaspoon cayenne pepper
Directions
Trim the butt lightly. Trim the fat cap down to about 1/4 inch and square off any thin, ragged edges that would burn. Leave the fat over the meat — it bastes the roast all day.
Bind and rub generously. Slather the butt with the yellow mustard, then coat every surface with the rub, pressing it in. Let the butt stand at room temperature while the smoker heats.
Set the butt fat-side up. Heat the smoker to 250°F. Set the butt in the center of the grate, fat side up, close the lid, and settle in — this cook is measured in hours, not minutes.
Smoke through the stall. Smoke undisturbed. Somewhere around 160°F the temperature will stall for hours as moisture evaporates — that is normal, not a malfunction. Hold the fire steady at 250°F and let it push through on its own.
Cook to probe-tender. Start checking at 195°F. The butt is done when a probe slides into the thickest part with almost no resistance and the bone wiggles loose — usually 195–205°F. If one spot still feels tight, give it another 30 minutes.
Rest, then pull by hand. Rest the butt, loosely tented, for 1 hour. Pull the meat into strands by hand or with two forks, discarding the bone and any large pockets of fat, and season the pulled meat with a pinch of leftover rub.
Grilling tip: Judge doneness by the probe, not the thermometer alone — two butts the same size can finish an hour apart, and tenderness is the real finish line.

