Pork Tenderloin , Sandwich , Smoking
Two tenderloins on Jim’s smoke,
One Greek, one garlic-fired,
Sliced thin on onion rolls,
With pickles — as required.
By day he covers Georgia —
Insurance is his trade;
But the policy his friends all love
Is the dinner Jim has made.
Best for: A friendly side-by-side — two tenderloins, two seasonings, one smoker — and a sandwich bar where everybody builds their own and argues for their favorite.
This one belongs to our friend Jim Harrington — insurance man by day at Harrington Insurance Agency, pitmaster by weekend — who smoked a pair of pork tenderloins and shared the cook with his friends, and it was too good an idea to leave on a feed. Jim’s move is the side-by-side: one tenderloin seasoned with Kinder’s Woodfired Garlic, the other with Cavender’s Greek seasoning, both smoked and sliced thin for sandwiches. Same meat, same fire, two completely different sandwiches.
The build is Jim’s, too: onion rolls, garlic aioli, provolone, and pickles. The provolone melts against the hot slices, the pickles cut the smoke, and the two seasonings keep every sandwich tasting like a decision. Thanks for the cook, Jim.
Grill: Low and slow in the smoker at 225–250°F, indirect heat. Equipment: Smoker or covered grill set up for indirect cooking, instant-read thermometer. Course: Main dish.
Ingredients
to 1 hour 15 minutes Rest: 10 minutes. Total: 1 hour 25 minutes to 1 hour 40 minutes.
Not sure when it’s done? Check the grilling temperatures & doneness chart.
The tenderloins
- 2 pork tenderloins, about 1 to 1 1/4 pounds each, trimmed of silverskin
- 2 tablespoons Kinder’s Woodfired Garlic seasoning
- 2 tablespoons Cavender’s All Purpose Greek Seasoning
- 1 teaspoon neutral oil, optional, to help the seasoning stick
The sandwiches
- 6 onion rolls
- 1/2 cup mayonnaise
- 2 cloves garlic, grated fine
- 1 teaspoon lemon juice
- 1 pinch fine sea salt
- 6 slices provolone cheese
- Dill pickle slices or chips
Directions
Trim and score. Trim the silverskin from both tenderloins, then score the surface in shallow diagonal cuts — just through the surface, never deep. The scoring gives the seasoning something to hold on to and helps the smoke take.
Season two ways. Coat one tenderloin generously with the Kinder’s Woodfired Garlic and the other with the Cavender’s Greek, pressing the seasoning in on all sides. Keep track of which is which — the whole point is the comparison. Let them stand while the smoker comes up to temperature.
Smoke low and slow. Set the smoker or covered grill for indirect heat at 225–250°F. Lay the tenderloins on the grate away from the coals, close the lid, and smoke until they are nearly done — tenderloin is a lean, quick cut, so this is a short smoke, not an all-day one.
Pull at 145°F and rest. The tenderloins are done at 145°F in the thickest part, about 1 hour to 1 hour 15 minutes in. Rest them 10 minutes, tented loosely — they will slice juicier for the wait, and the blush of pink in the middle is exactly right at this temperature.
Slice thin. Slice both tenderloins crosswise into thin medallions. Keep the two piles separate and set them out side by side so everyone can build one of each.
Build the sandwiches. Stir the mayonnaise, grated garlic, lemon juice, and salt into a quick garlic aioli. Toast the onion rolls, spread aioli on both sides, and layer on the hot pork — lay the provolone over the warm slices so it melts into them — then finish with pickles and the top roll. Jim served his with tater tots, and we are not about to improve on that.
Grilling tip: The side-by-side is the entertainment. Put both piles of pork on one board, label them with a toothpick flag if your crowd is competitive, and let the table vote — at Jim’s table, the rematch is just another pair of tenderloins away.

